Care to elaborate? In re-skimming his post I’m not seeing it. All I really want to use from that post is anti-epiphenomenalism; there is some in-universe, physically causal reason we are talking about consciousness.
  1
 
 
 
Ok maybe not circular but full of bad assumptions l 1. (unprovable) consciousness is a software program 2. the parts of the program we can measure have obvious utility 3. the parts we can’t measure are exactly like the parts that we can (dubious) 1/2
  1
 
 
  2